Thoughts on indigenous movements books?

05.08.2006

Technorati tags:

I'm going to spend the last 2½ weeks of my Latin American politics course at Dickinson (POSC 251-01) on indigenous movements. The rest of the semester is dedicated to a broad overview of the region, some democratization literature, and some readings on five major cases (Argentina, Brazil, Chile, Mexico, Cuba). I figured a good, timely, and interesting topic to focus on at the end of the semester — and after students' semester papers are due — would be the recent rise of indigenous movements.

I just received a review copy of Contemporary Indigenous Movements in Latin America, edited by Erick Langer (part of Rowman & Littlefield's Jaguar Books on Latin America series). I'm thinking of replacing Deborah Yashar's Contesting Citizenship in Latin America: The Rise of Indigenous Movements and the Postliberal Challenge w/ this other book. It's the difference between a 200-page edited volume (Langer) & a 400-page single-author book (Yashar). Any thoughts?

----
ADDENDUM: The other books I'm using are:

Posted by Miguel at 06:42 PM

Comments

not to sound completely like the pinche gringo on this one, but isn't two weeks a long time to spend on indigenous movements in [what i assume is] an undergraduate course?

I'd imagine the last week would be taken up by an hour of talking about "where does Latam politics go from here?" and an hour of telegraphing what will be on the final exam...

also, if you're looking for magazine articles for supplementary reading, i can make several recommendations...

Posted by: mike d at May 9, 2006 01:36 PM

Yes, two weeks may seem a bit long. But it's not just about indigenous movements, but also how it relates to democratization, globalization, etc. The Langer book I really like because it fits indigenous movements into the larger "social movements" or "civil society" literature, so it's not entirely "anthropological" or something like that. So it fits into our course on democratization in Latin America. I see indigenous movements as both a product of--and challenge to--democratization.

The Langer book is also critical of the role of NGOs & international actors in indigenous movements--particularly when they fetishize indigenous people's "exoticism" (he refers to the old "noble savage" mythos) to further their own agendas. So I like that it's not an "activist" book on the subject.

And last time I taught my Latin American politics course (at WMU), I spent two weeks on urban politics in Latin America as the special "theme" portion of the course. So I wanted to do something else (but not populism or parties, since I'm teaching a whole course just on that in the Spring).

Posted by: mcentellas [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 9, 2006 01:48 PM

I would go with the Yashar book. She sets up her theoretical framework in a concise way, sticks with it throughout, and it actually reads surprisingly well. Any undergrad poli-sci major would not only learn a lot about recent Latin American political developments, but it would also be a good tool to help them learn how to organize and present their ideas in writing.

Posted by: Boli-Nica at May 11, 2006 02:25 AM